Search This Blog

Friday, September 29, 2023

SPRAWL

 

Sprawl is the pattern of a parasite without a symbiotic future -- until we have the data, knowledge, and commitment needed to defend the argument that a Built Domain must shelter growing populations within geographic limits that protect its quality and source of life, the Natural Domain. (See my essay, “The Least a City Should Know”, at www.wmhosack.blogspot.com)

Photo by Chixoy

Thursday, September 21, 2023

The Principles of Shelter Capacity Evaluation for Urban Design and Economic Development

 

Before I get to the title of this essay I would like to mention an essay I remembered after reading an article about data dependent planning and urban design. The essay is entitled, “The Least a City Should Know”. It is located on my blog at www.wmhosack.blogspot.com. I am not attaching it for the sake of brevity since it is longer than I normally write and contains 7 tables. It is about the correlation of currently independent database sources that must agree to form a common resource before we can begin to correlate the information needed to build knowledge and make informed city planning and urban design decisions.

We cannot predict, plan, and lead shelter capacity decisions toward the efficient and economically stable use of limited land areas without improved database correlation. We do not need to leave these decisions to a marketplace that believes in land without end and private profitability without concern for public revenue potential and financial stability per acre of municipal land area.

In other words, we cannot correlate design of the physical city with its social and economic characteristics until we are able to assemble the relational databases required to understand the correlation of decisions involved.

Forecast Models for Shelter Capacity Measurement and Evaluation

I have written about the urban design classification system, building design categories, forecast models, design specification templates, architectural algorithms, master equations, and definitional equations that determine shelter capacity and intensity at the cellular level of city formation on many occasions; and have referred to the software package of measurement and forecasting models as both Shelter Capacity Evaluation and Development Capacity Evaluation.

I continue to vacillate between the terms “shelter capacity” and “development capacity”. Shelter has a residential tone but conveys the life-saving nature of the topic. Development is all-inclusive but has a less imperative, more diluted and commercial tone. When I use either of these terms, they are meant to encompass the building design categories, gross building areas, and shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications that can be mathematically predicted from design specification values entered in a building design category template. These predictions can be used for either residential or non-residential occupancy. They predict the shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications of contemplated design specification options, but the values chosen can be improved with a focused strategy of data accumulation, correlation, and evaluation.

Principles of Shelter Capacity Evaluation

While writing this I thought back to my creation of Shelter Capacity Evaluation software and would like to mention the points that have come to influence my opinions and approach. The number of variable decisions exposed by this exercise gave me a new appreciation for the mental correlation performed by architects, landscape architects, city planners, urban designers, and so on over centuries. They have had to perform this correlation with the leadership instinct, intuition, awareness, experience, and rules of thumb that we have called talent. It has been applied for centuries when population growth was encouraged and land was plentiful. We now need to support talent with a foundation of data accumulation, mathematical evaluation, and increasing knowledge that will help it consistently provide shelter for the activities of increasing populations within geographic limits defined to protect their quality and source of life. It will never replace talent, but it will give it more credible support for the decisions it recommends. The following opinions have led me to the formation of this mathematical foundation.

(1)              There are two worlds on a single planet – the Built Domain and the Natural Domain.

(2)              The Built Domain continues to consume agriculture and the Natural Domain with sprawl and annexation.

(3)              Human survival depends on shelter within the Built Domain.

(4)              The activities of growing populations depend on an increasing shelter supply.

(5)              Shelter is served within the Urban and Rural Phyla of the Built Domain by its Movement, Open Space, and Life Support Divisions.

(6)              Shelter is provided by 6 building design categories that can be mathematically defined.

(7)              Land consumption by a building design category is a function of the design specification values entered in its forecast model.

(8)              Building floor quantity options can be mathematically correlated with site plan design specifications to forecast gross building area alternatives for a given land area.

(9)              Gross building area divided by the buildable acres involved equals the shelter capacity per acre planned or present.

(10)            Shelter capacity times the impervious cover percentage planned or present on a given buildable land area divided by 10,000 equals the intensity present.

(11)            Intensity measurements and predictions can indicate excessive urban design alternatives.

(12)            Excessive intensity remains to be defined with case study measurements of existing building design category specifications.

(13)            Shelter capacity for activity has private financial and public economic development implications.

(14)            A city’s total expense per acre can be compared with the revenue it receives per census block, tract, or zoning district acre to determine financial stability and future urban design strategies.

(15)            Urban design strategies for shelter capacity, intensity, activity, and location can improve the revenue produced from areas within a city’s municipal area.

(16)            Shelter capacity forecasting combined with activity allocation in an urban design plan has economic implications that affect a city’s quality of life.

(17)            Existing building design specifications can be measured and evaluated using the topics listed in its related building category forecast model.

(18)            The composition and appearance of building mass, parking, pavement, and unpaved open space in a project area begins with the site planning and floor quantity specification values adopted as the urban design foundation for all ensuing design decisions.

(19)            Shelter project areas are cells with various amounts of shelter capacity, intensity, and activity that combine to form the Shelter Division of an urban anatomy.

(20)            The design specification measurements of an existing building are like the first blood pressure measurements in medicine. They require collection, correlation and evaluation to build knowledge of the capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance impact represented.

(21)        Sprawl is the pattern of a parasite withut a symbiotic future.

Observation

We have not, or have refused to recognize population growth as a threat to the preservation of agriculture and our source of life, the Natural Domain, even though we refer to this growth as “sprawl”. Sprawl is also a term associated in the minds of many with housing. It is actually unlimited land consumption for gross building area, often called annexation that can be used to shelter any activity. It is unlimited land consumption driven by population growth, deteriorating urban areas, shifting opinions, and use of inadequate forecasting tools that make it a threat to our source of life.

The need for shelter will continue to drive sprawl until we can correlate increasing demand within geographic areas limited to protect the natural domain without excessive shelter intensity. It has been an impossible goal because the shelter capacity of land and the intensity implications of optional, qualitative design decisions have resisted accurate mathematical definition and prediction. This has left population growth and sprawl as a debate without a frame of reference beyond conflicting opinion. I have created the measurement and prediction software of Shelter Capacity Evaluation to offer an alternative.


Wednesday, September 13, 2023

A Transition from Zoning to Urban Design

 


The word “balance” in city planning, urban design, landscape architecture, architectural design, and so on has been a goal without a definition and a criticism without adequate explanation. Zoning law attempted the first definition in an effort to protect the public, health, safety, and welfare. Its original intent was the separation of incompatible activity. It also recognized at the time that shelter intensity, intrusion, and dominance could combine to produce inadequate light, air, and ventilation that also threatened the public health, safety, and welfare. It was relatively easy to list activities permitted in a zone to avoid incompatibility. It has been impossible to consistently avoid excessive shelter intensity, intrusion, dominance and sprawl. The ingredients of intensity have never been comprehensively understood and their interaction has never been mathematically correlated. As a result, the laws produced without correlation have not been able to restrain excessive shelter intensity at one end of the spectrum, sprawl at the other, and annexation of agriculture and the Natural Domain for both.

The problem began with a failure to distinguish between zoning regulations that are independent and those that require mathematical correlation to achieve a common objective. Independent regulations do not depend on each other. As an example, you may not park an RV in your driveway for more than 24 hours and you may not erect a fence in your front yard. These are independent, cumulative requirements. The list goes on and continues to accumulate.

It has been a mistake to consider building height and parking quantity requirements as independent. In fact, it has been a mistake to consider any of the topics identified by a shaded cell in Table 1 as independent for the G1 Building Design Category. They must be mathematically correlated to define the gross building area potential of a given land area and the intensity produced. At the present time, we simply do ot understand what the intensity measurements in Col. G imply because we have not measured existing conditions. The failure to do so has wasted land and accounted for innumerable variance requests, public hearings, and contentious results seeking to reconcile the independent contradictions encountered. The result has often been excessive intensity, sprawl, and unlimited annexation of agriculture and the natural domain.

BACKGROUND

The items identified with a shaded cell in Table 1 are keystone urban design topics. Their values combine to determine the intensity, or “balance”, present or proposed. They do not lend themselves to independent regulation without first determining their mathematical correlation.

This is the first time I have stressed the word “correlation”, but I have discussed the building design categories, forecast models, architectural algorithms, and master equations that make it possible on many occasions. I’ll attempt to briefly summarize for any new readers by borrowing excerpts from previous essays and referring to Table 1.

 BUILDING DESIGN CATEGORIES

I’ve written about the six building design categories in the Shelter Division of the Urban and Rural Phyla of the Built Domain many times, and repeat them here simply as a reminder. They are: (1) G1 buildings with grade parking around, but not under, the building on the same premise; (2) G2 buildings with grade parking around and under the building; (3) S1 buildings with adjacent parking structure on the same premise; (4) S2 buildings served by underground parking structures; (5) S3 buildings with parking structures above grade under the building; (6) NP buildings with no parking required. I have also included a set of shelter capacity and property demand forecast models for independent parking garages (PG) in a book I will mention at the end of this essay, even though I don’t consider them buildings for human habitation unless dictated by an emergency.

DESIGN SPECIFICATIONS

I have included Table 1 in many essays and am repeating it here as an example of a complete, correlated set of design specification topics and values for the G1 Building Design Category.

There are 26 shaded cells in Table 1 for the G1.L1 forecast model. Each shaded value entered in a cell is correlated by an algorithm to produce the values needed by the master equation in cell J47. This equation produces the gross building area options in cells B44-B53. I mention this to make the point that regulating each shaded value independently is a hopeless exercise. The isolated values chosen will often conflict unless served by the mathematical correlation provided by the algorithm and master equation.

The shaded cells in Table 1 are not intended to replace an entire zoning ordinance. They identify the design specification topics that require correlation to lead G1 shelter capacity toward its intended intensity, activity, and economic development goals. (Keep in mind that the gross building area capacity of land may be occupied by any activity.)

Shelter intensity has been a term without adequate definition ever since its presence was recognized with instinct, intuition, awareness, and observation. Density and the Floor Area Ratio have been easy to measure but they have missed many of the controlling topics that must be correlated to provide shelter massing and intensity leadership. Every designer intuitively understands the principle of correlation. It is what he/she does. Unfortunately, the process can be too easily disrupted by independent zoning regulations that do not recognize the correlation required to consistently produce a balanced shelter pattern and composition to support a desired quality of life.

FORECAST PANEL

Gross building area prediction in cells B44-B52 is the first objective in the Forecast Panel of Table 1. They area keystone values that set the stage for all ensuing design decisions; and are the basis for shelter capacity calculation in cells F44-F53. (Shelter capacity equals gross building area divided by the buildable acres calculated from cell G10.) The other predictions in the forecast panel add essential design detail to the forecast.

IMPLICATIONS MODULE

The Implications Module measures the consequences of the values entered in the Design Specification Template of Table 1. The final intensity and dominance columns in the panel measure the results produced by the correlated values entered in the shaded cells of Table 1. These values make measurement, evaluation and knowledge accumulation feasible.

The shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance impact of the gross building area options in cells B44-B53 is calculated with the equations on line 43 of the Implications Module. I am not providing an evaluation of these impact measurements since this is a hypothetical example; but measurement, evaluation, and accumulated knowledge is the leadership promise offered by this system of building classification, design specification, planning prediction, and implication measurement.

CONCLUSION

A zoning ordinance is a collection of laws governing permitted site plan, building height and occupant activity on land within a zoning district of a government jurisdiction. Its original intent was the separation of incompatible project activity that threatened the public health, safety, and welfare. It was also recognized at the time that shelter intensity, intrusion, and dominance could combine to produce inadequate light, air, and ventilation that also threatened the public health, safety, and welfare. It was relatively easy to list the activities permitted in a zone. It has been impossible to avoid excessive shelter intensity, intrusion, dominance and sprawl with our current measures of density and the floor area ratio.

The ingredients of intensity, intrusion, and dominance have never been comprehensively understood and the interaction of these ingredients has never been mathematically correlated. Table 1 was introduced to give you a glimpse of the topics and correlation involved for one building design category. The independent, incomplete zoning laws written without correlation have simply produced contradictions, variance requests, and excessive intensity at one end of the spectrum with sprawl at the other; and annexation of agriculture and the Natural Domain for both. These regulations are not correlated to lead project design decisions toward cumulative project compositions of building mass, parking, pavement, and unpaved open space that combine to produce economic stability and a balanced quality of life within geographic limits.

Architectural Awareness

I began as an architect and city planner believing that architectural appearance could trump the excessive intensity often permitted by local zoning ordinances since I was either: (1) stuck with the land a client owned and asked to make it work; or (2) asked to predict the development capacity of potential land areas that needed to work. I slowly realized that urban design leadership and economic development was not the goal. The comprehensive mathematical correlation required was not understood by the framers of these legal requirements. Zoning was still attempting to separate incompatible land uses and provide adequate light, air, and ventilation with incomplete, independent, and often conflicting design regulations. They were not a leadership guide with clear massing objectives linked to economic development goals with forecasting models that could predict alternatives and the intensity implied with a few keystrokes.

Unfortunately, urban design topics are not isolated but some are independent zoning topics. They all require mathematical correlation, however. This correlation will directly affect the activity and intensity we encourage as well as the financial stability we produce. We cannot lead the Shelter Division of our Built Domain toward any strategic objectives that preclude consumption of agriculture and the Natural Domain until we can predict the correlated implications of our shelter design decisions.

Zoning Laws

Zoning laws are independent and cumulative but not correlated at the present time. It is like a language limited by intransitive verbs. The design specifications and architectural algorithms of development capacity forecasting models are the transitive values needed to create an urban design language that can step from monosyllables to leadership and knowledge. For instance, building height regulations are not coordinated with parking requirements. Each is an ingredient. The conflict often generates time-consuming variance requests. Zoning laws simply do not recognize the mathematical correlation required to provide an adequate leadership foundation. The result has too often been excessive intensity, sprawl, and unlimited annexation of agriculture and the natural domain for more of the same.

Master Plans

A master plan is a two-dimensional plan created to separate incompatible land use activities. Zoning regulations amplify the intent of the plan. This includes three-dimensional requirements intended to provide adequate light, air, and ventilation to the street. The problem has been a lack of mathematical correlation that could lead to the physical, social, psychological, environment, and economic relationships implied by our historic reference to Built Domain “balance”.

Summary

“I have contributed the conceptual framework and technical information needed to continue this discussion in my book, “The Equations of Urban Design”. It is available on Amazon.com but the title may have been an unfortunate choice since the book is not consumed with equations. They are simply the foundation on which the conceptual, predictive, measurement, and evaluation format of an urban design language is based. I have also published over 200 essays regarding this topic at my blog www.wmhosack.blogspot.com. It has been visited by over 38,000 readers.

There is a lot of work to be done to reach the only goal that matters. Our habitat must cease to be a threat to ourselves and its source of life – the Natural Domain.”

Walter M. Hosack: September, 2023



Wednesday, August 16, 2023

A Glimpse Into the Shelter Capacity Spectrum

 

The public right to protect its health, safety, and welfare from inadequate property owner provisions of light, air, ventilation, sanitation, hygiene, fire safety, dwelling area and so on brought us planning, zoning, and building regulation at the beginning of the 20th century. This was followed by building codes; master plans that anticipated unlimited annexation; and zoning codes that did not correlate independent regulations concerning density, parking, building height, yard setbacks, and so on. These independent zoning requirements couldn’t avoid contradiction because they lacked the mathematical correlation that can only be provided by architectural algorithms or the mind of a qualified and talented designer. There is no substitute for the creative ability to produce uniquely successful projects, but a mathematically correlated leadership foundation can be created as a substitute for the random regulation that addresses isolated topics of architectural design without calculating their combined implications, including excessive intensity within a sprawling urban fabric.

You will read about the potential to define mathematically correlated platforms for shelter design leadership by all related city design professions. It will involve terms like building design category, forecast model, design specification template, buildable land area, impervious cover, unpaved open space, shelter area, core area, parking specification, floor quantity, gross building area, building footprint, and the shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications of correlated design specification decisions. I hope these terms are not new to you since I’ve written about them often in the past. If they are, I think you will understand as you read. They will introduce you to the spectrum of development capacity options that will determine your ability to define and shelter the activities of growing populations within the composition of a limited Built Domain that is needed to protect our quality and source of life – the Natural Domain.

The Baseline

The maximum gross building area (GBA) potential of a given land area will be the baseline for this discussion. I’m going to use the forecast model G1.L1 in Table 1, and its master equation in cell B39, to establish this baseline and address the potential I’ve mentioned with something more than intuition and experience. I’ve discussed this table many times and have included the derivation of its master equation in my book, The Equations of Urban Design. The table addresses the (G1) Building Design Category when gross land area (L1) is given in cell F3. As a reminder, the G1 category includes all buildings served by a grade parking lot around, but not under, the building on the same premise. (A building design category may be occupied by any occupant activity more commonly referred to as a “land use”. The emphasis here is not on the compatibility of adjacent land use activity, but on the shelter capacity of a given land area. Capacity and condition encourages or discourages activity. Shelter capacity, condition, and location deficiencies discourage economic development.)

The workhorse for this discussion is Table1. It will be used to create Tables 2 and 3. The parking assumptions in Table 1 have been entered in cells A35 and A36. Floor quantity options have been entered in cells A49-A53; and an assumed gross land area has been entered in cell F3. The remaining shaded cell variables have been entered as zero to find the maximum development capacity of the land area given the parking specifications entered. The result is a prediction of gross building area potential (GBA) in cells B44-B53 for each of the floor quantity options entered in cells A44-A53. All of these forecasts are related to the land area given in cell F3. The predictions represent the maximum gross building area potential of the land area given when the project area is covered by parking lot and building footprint when the unpaved open space allocation in cell F11 is zero. This is an extreme condition but establishes one end of the potential development capacity spectrum for this building design category, land area, and parking specification.

A Unique G1 Characteristic

Before I go further, I’d like to point out why I’ve drawn a line under floor quantity 5 in Tables 1, 2 and 3. The line emphasizes a unique characteristic of the G1.L1 Building Design Category. I’ve mentioned this before so I ask previous readers to excuse the repetition.

When the value entered in cell A35 of Table 1 exceeds the value entered in cell A36, the surface parking lot will expand at a greater rate than the building footprint. Parking quantity and area must expand to justify increases in gross building area produced by increased floor quantities as the building footprint area declines. This parking lot expansion eventually shrinks the remaining building footprint area below a useful floor plan area.

The gross building area (GBA) increase per floor is calculated in cells B44-B53 of Table 1 based on the values entered for (s) and (a) in cells A35 and A36 of its Design Specification Template. These GBA values are repeated in Column B of Table 2. The increase per floor becomes negligible above 5 because of the relationship just mentioned. The line added below the 5 floor mark emphasizes this characteristic. The request for parking variances begins when the futility of increased floor quantity is recognized. Parking variances increase gross building area potential because they reduce the parking lot area required and expand the potential building footprint area. They also increase intensity that has been unmeasurable in the past. The variances, however, do not affect the 5 floor characteristic just mentioned.

The (GBA) predictions made in cells B44-B53 of Table 1 represent the maximum (GBA) potential of the land area given the values entered in the Design Specification Template of Table 1. A change to one or more of these values would produce a new forecast.

Shelter Capacity

I also need to introduce the concept of shelter capacity as a prerequisite to the remainder of this discussion. Gross building area calculations do not indicate the land area consumed. I have created shelter capacity calculations for this reason. The shelter capacity of a given buildable land area is equal to the gross building area square feet planned or present divided by the buildable land area involved in acres. The resulting dividend is shelter capacity per acre (SFAC). The calculation makes all building projects mathematically comparable to the land consumed and has the added benefit of enabling calculation of the intensity, intrusion, and dominance implied by the physical presence measured.

Shelter capacity (SFAC) is calculated in cells F44-F53 of Table 1 based on the equation in cell F43; the gross building area values calculated in cells B44-B53; and the buildable land area calculated in cell G10. In this example, the shelter capacity calculations represent the maximum development capacity of the 1.738 acre land area given based on the design specification values and floor quantity options entered in Table 1.  

The relationship between land, building, pavement, and open space will demand increasing attention as populations continue to expand and we come to realize that land preservation beyond our Built Domain is a mandate and not a choice.

Column B4-B13 in Table 2 repeats the shelter capacity values calculated in cells F44-F53 of Table 1. The remaining columns reflect the changes that occur when the zero unpaved open space value in cell F11 of Table 1 is replaced by the values in cells B3-M3 of Table 2. Each column in Table 2 calculates the shelter capacity produced in Table 1 for the floor quantity options entered in cells A4-A13 when the unpaved open space percentage is amended to equal the constant at the top of each column in Table 2.

Reading across rows 4-13 in Table 2 defines the shelter capacity reductions that occur when the unpaved open space percentage increases in row 3.

When all design specification values remain constant in the G1.L1 forecast model (except for the unpaved open space percentage in cell F11), Table 2 shows that: (1) increasing the unpaved open space percentage (S) required on the buildable land area (BLA) of a project will reduce the gross building area (GBA) potential of the area, and (2) an increased floor quantity (f) cannot recover a GBA loss when a significantly greater unpaved open space percentage (S) is required.

The entire range of shelter capacity implications associated with the unpaved open space increases in cells B3-L3 are shown in the columns of Table 2.The intensity implications of the increased unpaved open space allocations in Table 2 are recorded in Table 3. Both of these tables have been created from Table 1 by modifying the unpaved open space percentage in cell F11 of Table 1 to equal each of the percentages in Row 3 of Table 2 and Row 23 of Table 3.

Intensity

Physical intensity is a condition we feel but haven’t been able to measure. I doubt, however, that many will disagree that it has an effect on those adjacent to, or surrounded by, its presence. In fact, I believe that physical intensity has at the very least a social, psychological, environmental, and economic impact. This is why I created the Implication Module in Table 1. It measures intensity in relation to the building design categories and design specification decisions that determine its scope.

The Implications Module in Table 1 is based on the gross building area (GBA) predictions in cells B44-B53. It first measures shelter capacity (SFAC) in Column F for each of its GBA predictions. It then measures the intensity (INT), intrusion (INTR), and dominance (DOM) implied by the shelter capacity calculations in its succeeding columns using the equations in cells F43, G43, H43, and J43.

Table 3 records the intensity created per floor when the open space in Row 23 increases to mirror the increases in Row 3 of Table 2. As expected, intensity declines with the increasing percentage of unpaved open space provided per floor and increases within each open space category as floor quantity increases.

Tables 2 and 3 calculate the capacity and intensity options related to the design specifications entered in Table 1. The additional options that could be produced are not hard to imagine when you realize that there are 26 shaded design specification locations in Table 1, and that Tables 2 and 3 will change whenever one or more of these shaded values is modified.

It is inevitable that shelter design decisions become a guessing game with sprawl and excessive intensity as potential outcomes when the palette of design specification decisions is not understood mathematically correlated and intensity targets are not defined with knowledge based on pre-existing research.

Choice

Table 1 uses extreme design specification choices to define one end of the development capacity spectrum when parking value (s) equals 400 and (a) equals 250. The shelter capacity limits in Column B of Table 2 and the intensity levels in Column B of Table 3 measure the implications of these extreme choices. The remaining columns C-M in Table 2 present the shelter capacity reductions that occur when unpaved open space percentages increase in cells C4-M4.

The intensity levels in Columns C-M of Table 3 also decline with the increased unpaved open space percentages in Table 2. The tables clarify the choices available and implications involved. There are many more than presented. They change whenever one or more design specification values in the shaded cells of Table 1 change. The choices are in our hands. Measurement and evaluation of existing projects can help us understand the related consequences of design specifications, shelter capacity, and intensity decisions for all building design categories within a correlated mathematical spectrum of shelter capacity options. Evaluating these choices can help us acquire a better understanding of the places we create around the shelter we inhabit within the limited Built Domain we must define.

Walter M. Hosack: August, 2023



Photo by David Brooke Martin on Unsplash

 


Wednesday, July 26, 2023

A Mathematical Form and Pattern Language for City Design

Letter to Dr. Mohammed ouda, Ph.D


 I have spent many years attempting to correlate two-dimensional urban patterns with their three-dimensional implications using mathematics. These patterns grow one cell at a time to produce the urban form we inhabit. Some results have been referred to as sprawl and others as excessive intensity. Neither has had an adequate leadership definition preventing us from repeating these results. (These cells are more commonly referred to as lots, parcels, projects, and so on.)

My effort has focused on the characteristics and growth options for an individual shelter cell since it combines with others to form a Shelter Division served by the Movement, Open Space, and Life Support Divisions of its Built Domain anatomy. The effort has involved a new building design classification format, new design specification templates related to each building design category (BDC), template algorithms that distill the values entered to produce the values needed by a BDC master equation, and gross building area options predicted by the equation based on the floor quantity alternatives entered in the template after all other relevant two-dimensional site plan design value percentages are entered.

The result is a prediction of gross building area alternatives related to the floor quantity options entered. When these gross building area options are divided by the buildable acres identified, the result is a series of shelter capacity alternatives that have physical intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications that be calculated.

The design specification values related to existing projects can also be measured for evaluation. The implication calculations will form a new language based on measurement and evaluation that we can call the science of city design. It is perfectly suited to landscape architecture, urban design, and city planning. It requires no architectural prerequisites to address the form and pattern of an urban anatomy that cannot continue to grow and indefinitely consume its source of life with sprawl and excessive intensity.

I have written four books and over 200 essays on this subject. The essay list can be found on my blog at www.wmhosack.blogspot.com. My last book is entitled, “The Equations of Urban Design” and is available from Amazon.com at a very nominal price. It contains my attempt to correlate two-dimensional patterns with their three-dimensional physical implications using a new scientific language based on the persuasive vocabulary of mathematics as its foundation. I have made the effort because I believe we need the language to speak in more credible and convincing terms based on measurement, evaluation, and accumulation of lasting knowledge to support ephemeral design talent.

Walter M. Hosack: July, 2023

Monday, July 3, 2023

Confronting Sprawl: with the language & mathematics required to build knowledge and leadership credibility

I don’t believe the use of land to shelter increasing population activity has been seriously considered a threat to our survival. If it has at some intellectual level, the concern has not been converted to a definition of sustainable geographic limits for cities that protect agriculture and the Natural Domain. We continue to rely on unlimited annexation to expand the land area needed to shelter the activities of increasing populations, and this continues to consume our source of life with sprawl.

The law of limits for all other species is a simple equation related to the land available. We are no different, but have considered land as property and a convertible commodity without limit. Part of this attitude, I believe, is due to our incredibly small individual presence on the planet; hubris that fails to recognize our parasitic behavior; and an inability to lead shelter capacity decisions with the abstract comprehension, measurement, prediction, and evaluation required. We represent microscopic activity expanding in a petri dish being observed by a universe that will not intervene to diagnose and treat behavior that exceeds the planet’s law of limits. We are expected to recognize the obligation.

There is no question in my mind that there is a power beyond our comprehension, but I don’t believe it exists to save us from ourselves. We have been given guidance, permitted choice, and are expected to make the right decisions.

In the case of shelter for the activities of growing populations, it is one of four divisions in the Urban and Rural Phyla of a Built Domain that is in competition with our source of life - the Natural Domain. The other three divisions serve the Shelter Division and provide the movement, open space, and life support infrastructure it needs to survive.

The path we follow in our cities will depend on our ability to build knowledge that can lead us away from unlimited sprawl. This direction will not be provided by divine guidance. We must acquire the knowledge needed to define direction and correlate the many professions that must contribute. Until then, we seem to have concluded that we can rely on citizen participation for decisions. I hope to show in this essay that this participation cannot command the detail required to plan the strategy needed for leadership. The goal is rather self-evident. We must learn to shelter the activities of growing populations within a geographically limited Built Doman designed to protect their quality and source of life – the Natural Domain.

I have mentioned this topic in many essays. At its heart has been a conviction that we do not have the city design language needed to step beyond conflict over opinion with the measurement, evaluation, and prediction needed to build knowledge, gain credibility, and introduce restraint within a political environment that does not recognize the issue as one of survival. The protection of health, safety, and welfare has helped us to survive. It has overlooked the implications of unlimited growth and consumption on a planet that is no longer a “land without end”.

Our course can be adjusted by classifying building design categories in a way that permits us to accurately measure and predict the shelter capacity of land and the intensity these options imply. This is relevant because the combination of gross building area and activity on a given land area produces shelter capacity, intensity, and economic productivity per buildable acre. It may take a minute to digest this, but may come into focus when I point out that gross building can be occupied by any activity. Compatibility of activity has been a city planning concern, but the quantity of activity and its revenue potential per square foot and per buildable acre has been a mystery that determines a city’s financial stability. In other words, a land use activity plan without a correlated gross building area and condition plan will struggle to define a stable financial strategy over time. It will be forced to fight endless tactical battles over project proposals with only a vague understanding of the role they will play in a comprehensive financial strategy. Calculated correlation of these relationships on every lot within a city’s land use plan will indicate its current economic stability, quality of life, and future course of action; since the average annual revenue received per buildable acre in a city should equal its average annual cost per acre to provide essential services. If the imbalance is great enough, the debate over the definition of “essential” begins as budget cuts become an issue. 

I should also mention that excessive gross building area on a given land area produces excessive intensity. Intensity seeking to magnify profit has been a term without a definition and source of frequent conflict. Floor quantity is only one of many design specification topics that combine to form intensity. Those who have read some of my previous essays have read about these topics and the correlation involved. I won’t repeat myself here for the sake of brevity. I’ll simply mention that intensity is a function of shelter capacity and can now be measured. The relationship of intensity to gross building area and activity determines the revenue potential of a given land area, and the physical dominance introduced within the urban pattern we inhabit.

The objective is to accurately predict gross building area and intensity options for a given land area based on the design specification decisions entered in a building category’s forecast model. This definition is not only useful for prediction. The specification topics can also be measured at existing locations to benchmark a host of related observations and evaluations from many professional perspectives. I think we may agree that measurement can lead to knowledge.

I would like to introduce the entire list of building design categories, activity groups, and master equations I have proposed. It is included on three pages as Table 1. I am not including the digital templates that permit a set of design specifications for a building design category to be evaluated with a few keystrokes. They are beyond the scope of this limited format. I hope you get acquainted, since the cellular structure of a city currently represents the anatomy of a parasite that does not understand the discipline required to survive.

The master equations referenced in Table 1 have been included to show they exist. I have not included explanations for the abbreviations shown and derivations involved. My primary objective has been to present the classification needed to proceed with the evaluation of design specification decisions and shelter capacity implications.

POSTSCRIPT

Economic development will continue to struggle until it can accurately correlate shelter capacity with activity, intensity, and revenue on every lot in a city. At this point it can begin to understand the current and future potential of the land involved. This is when strategic discussions can begin with the information needed. Until then, cities will continue their annual dance with deficits and city design opinion will continue seeking a stronger foundation.

Walter M. Hosack: July, 2023







Sunday, June 18, 2023

Correlating the Decisions that Create Density

Density in terms of dwelling units per acre is a definition containing two ambiguities and a lack of correlation that has compromised its leadership ability. There is a better way to define an objective that has global significance.

The first ambiguity is an unspecified percentage of the acre that is available for shelter construction. This immediately makes physical intensity an unmeasurable quantity. As an example, portions of the acre may be required for public right-of-way. In this case a “gross acre” is reduced to an available “net area”. Portions of the net area may be consumed by ravines, protected wetlands, streams, and so on. The remainder then becomes a “buildable land area”. Portions of the buildable area may be devoted to common open space shared by a number of dwelling units. In this case the remainder becomes a “shelter area”. A density calculation or regulation that does not accurately define the area on which it is based introduces uncertain intensity, ambiguity, and argument.

The second ambiguity is an unspecified maximum dwelling unit area for the quantity permitted per acre. This problem is easiest to visualize by considering the same dwelling unit on decreasing land areas. The result is increasing amounts of physical intensity, intrusion, and dominance, but we have been unable to calculate or measure these implications. We have simply formed opinions based on individual perception.

The following discussion will explain the measurement topics that are required to adequately define density and predict future implications in the leadership detail required. The template used will address one building design category occupied by one activity group. The format is similar, but not identical, for all forecast models related to six building design categories that are occupied by a wide variety of activity groups around the globe. The alternative is simply a continuation of the methods that have brought us annexation, sprawl, and continuing consumption of both agriculture and the land of our natural domain. I have frequently explained this category classification in the past and will avoid duplication here for the sake of brevity.

Density does not lead shelter design decisions. It is a product of them. The broad design discretion permitted by the concept, and the lack of correlation among its variable determinants, has produced random results fashioned with opinion. Annexation and sprawl symbolize the continuing leadership confusion with excessive land consumption. This isn’t the first time I’ve said this, but I keep trying to simplify the explanation.

It takes a correlated set of design value decisions to determine density, and these measurable decisions have shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications that can be measured. I intend to explain one set in this brief essay. Many optional design specification values are not desirable, but this remains to be proven with evaluation of accurate, measureable analysis. The objective is simple and probably controversial. We must learn to live within a geographically limited Built Domain that shelters the many activities of growing populations while protecting their quality of life and their source of life – the Natural Domain. We cannot do this with a random approach that depends on opinion without an adequate foundation of acquired knowledge.

I’m going to explain density by leading you through the 51 measureable design specification decisions that lead to this conclusion in the example I have chosen. It will also show that these decisions produce measureable capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications that we either enjoy or endure within the Shelter Division of our cities. Correlation of these decisions is the key. Quality of life and economic potential are outcomes encouraged by the right decisions.

THE FORECAST MODEL

The following example begins with a given gross land area, a given building design category, and apartment activity as the given occupant group. If you have read my earlier work you will recognize the G1.R3.L1 Forecast Model included as Table 1. The notation “G1” refers to all buildings served by surface parking around but not under the building on the same premise. The notation “R3” refers to gross building areas subdivided to contain three or more single floor apartment “flats” for residential activity. The notation “L1” indicates that gross land area must be given.

Currently, activities are grouped under the term “land use category” rather than “activity group”. This has confused the distinction between a building design category and an occupant activity. This essay is based on a shelter classification system that contains six building design categories occupied by most, if not all, activity groups around the planet. A building design category may be occupied by an activity. It is the correlation of shelter capacity with activity on land that determines the economic potential of the land as well as the physical intensity introduced. We have had to rely on opinion and rules of thumb to assess these opportunities. Opinion is enough to debate the merits of fine art; but only enough to start the measurement and evaluation needed to proceed with an effort to build transferrable knowledge regarding shelter capacity, intensity, and economic stability.

Land Module

This explanation begins with the Land Module in Table 1. Gross land area given in shaded cell F3. An unbuildable land area percentage is requested in cell F4. The area percentages to be set aside for existing conditions to remain and future expansion are requested in cells F5 and F6. Subtraction produces the net land area percentage remaining in cell F7. The percentage of net land area estimated for public right-of-way is requested in cell F8. Subtraction of this area from net area produces the buildable land area remaining in cell F10. The percentage of buildable land area to be set aside for unpaved open space is requested in cell F11. The impervious cover remaining for building cover and all other pavement is found in cell F12 by subtracting the value entered in cell F11 from 100%. Portions of the project area unpaved open space and impervious cover remaining in the buildable land area may be devoted to common area serving more than one building in a larger project area. If so, the percentages of buildable land area contemplated are requested in cells F13 and F14. Common space allocation, when introduced, reduces the impervious cover and unpaved open space percentages of buildable land area remaining. These reductions, if present, are shown in cells F15 and F16. The sum of the impervious cover and unpaved open space percentages remaining in cells F16 and F17 produce the remaining project shelter area in cell F17. Finding this value is the objective of the Land Module.

Core Module

The objective of the Core Module is to subtract all additional estimated miscellaneous impervious cover percentages that reduce total impervious cover percentage in the shelter area. Subtraction finds the core area remaining for building cover and surface parking in cell F32. Defining this core area makes the derivation of a master equation capable of predicting gross building area options for the core area feasible.

The master equation is located in cell B51, but the values (a), (f), and (s) in the equation remain to be defined. The value (f) represents floor quantity. The values under consideration are entered as options in cells A56-A65. The value (a) represents the gross building area square feet that may be constructed per parking space provided. The value (s) represents the average parking lot square feet per parking space planned or provided. Both are found using the R3 Apartment Module.

R3 Apartment Module

I mentioned at the beginning of this essay that density expression does not specify the average dwelling unit area (ADU) used to produce the density involved. It also omits the values (s) and (a) from its definition. These omissions can produce a wide range of shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance results.  The R3 Apartment Module has been used to find these values and make the prediction of gross building area (GBA) options feasible with the use of the master equation in cell B51.

The dwelling unit types planned are entered in cells A41-A45. The percentage allocation for each type is entered in cells B41-B45. The habitable area planned for each is entered in cells C41-C45. These habitable areas are increased by the efficiency factor entered in cell F37 to determine the estimated gross building area required for each habitable area in cells D41-D45. The average dwelling unit area involved (ADU) is calculated from the data entered and calculated in cell D47.

The number of garage spaces planned for each dwelling unit type is entered in cells E41-E45. The number of parking spaces planned for each dwelling unit type is entered in cells F41-F45. The average parking area per parking space for all dwelling units planned (a) is calculated in cell J47.

The value (s) is a design variable decision entered in cell F36. The value chosen has a great deal to do with the landscape quality anticipated for the parking lot.

I’ve already mentioned that master equation value (f) is represented by a series of floor quantity options entered in cells A56-A65.

The master equation in cell B51 is the product of an extensive derivation that is not included for the sake of brevity.

At this point I hope it is clear that design value decisions must be entered in the 51 shaded cells of Table 1 before their density implication can be accurately calculated by the master equation in cell B51. Omitting this information introduces too much ambiguity for adequate leadership within a limited Built Domain that must be constrained from consuming its agriculture and source of life.

Planning Forecast Panel

The gross building area (GBA) options calculated in cells B56-B65 of Table 1 have been the objective of this forecast model, and they are a function of the values entered in the shaded cells of Table 1. A change to one or more of these values would produce different forecast results since they are all correlated. This should indicate the sensitivity of the correlation that has been managed with instinct, intuition, and talent for centuries. When these gross building area options are divided by the buildable acres involved, the options that result are presented as shelter capacity (SFAC) options in cells J56-J65.

The calculation of gross building area options for a given land area makes any number of related predictions feasible. A few are calculated with simple arithmetic in Columns C-H of the Planning Forecast Panel as examples of this potential. I won’t spend time with them since they are relatively self-explanatory.

Implications Module

I’ve previously mentioned that an inability to accurately calculate gross building area and shelter capacity per buildable acre can result in estimations that either waste land or produce excessive intensity on inadequate land area. The Implications Module introduces a method of measuring shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance that will be produced by a given or measured set of design specifications.

An example set of specifications has been entered in the 51 shaded cells of Table 1. The implications calculated in Columns J-M of the Implications Module are like the first blood pressure measurements. We will not understand their meaning until we measure and evaluate a test group of project areas to understand the unwritten knowledge they convey.

I’ve included density per shelter acre (dSHAC) and density per gross acre (dGAC) in Columns M and N to show how density implications are a product of the leadership decisions entered in the 51 shaded cells of Table 1. As an isolated requirement without the specifications provided, it is simply too imprecise to lead these decisions toward a desired objective.

Dwelling Unit Forecast Panel

The forecast panel beginning on Row 67 of both Tables 1 and 2 is provided to help assess the design implications of the design specification values entered and the floor quantity entered in cell B70. The rounded dwelling unit quantities calculated on Row 71 are intended as a guide, not as a floor plan solution. 

Postscript

I’m going to ask you to imagine for a moment. If you, your client, or an applicant filled in the values requested in the shaded boxes of Table 1 on paper, you could enter them in the digital template illustrated to determine their implications. If prior research and evaluation had defined capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance targets, the specification could either be approved or modified with a few keystrokes to meet them. This doesn’t mean that all differences of opinion regarding the values entered can be resolved without recourse to a Zoning Board of Adjustment. It simply provides a more objective, efficient, and comprehensive common platform for evaluation by all parties involved.

               Unpaved Open Space – Stormwater

This is a topic that has been largely ignored in the quest to increase the permitted number of dwelling units on a given land area with the least expense. If I reduced the unpaved open space percentage specified in shaded cell F11 of Table 1 to that shown in Table 2, the dwelling unit quantities in Column D of the Table 2 Forecast Panel increase along with the densities calculated in Columns M and N of the Implications Module. The impervious cover percentage in cell F11 also increases.

Density approval of the increase requested can often overlook the storm sewer capacity required by the increased impervious cover. Later variance approvals for more impervious cover on the same lots can easily increase the problem. The conflict between public benefit and private expense should be obvious. I won’t expand on the issue since I’ve discussed it in previous essays. I note it here because it is one reason for the unpaved open space percentage requested for evaluation in cell F11 of Table 1, and the resulting maximum impervious cover percentage that is calculated in cell F12. These values would apply to all future variance requests as well. If a city defines these percentages and insists on recording these decisions to protect its infrastructure, it will need to depend on accurate site plan review of the percentages requested in the future.

Cell Aggregation

Table 1 is a design specification for a single project area, or cell, in the Shelter Division of our Built Domain. Cells aggregate to form an urban anatomy we call cities in a Built Domain we have failed to recognize as a parasite. The challenge is to measure and design every existing and proposed cell in this domain using forecast models to conserve land and encourage economic stability with the same intensity that we devote to weather evaluation. The anatomy of the Built Domain has not been born in symbiotic harmony with the planet. It has grown under mistaken assumptions. City design with authority is the only remedy available.

Walter M. Hosack: June, 2023




Friday, June 2, 2023

Making the Argument for Shelter Capacity Evaluation


 I have pursued the proposition that we must learn to shelter the many activities of growing populations within limited geographic areas, without excessive intensity; since it seems self-evident that we cannot continue to consume the land for expanding shelter and cities indefinitely -- without consuming our source of life. This effort has produced a new building design category classification system and related series of forecast models for gross building area prediction, measurement, evaluation, knowledge formation, and leadership improvement. The emphasis has been on the gross building area potential of land, the shelter capacity options per buildable acre available, and the intensity implies, since shelter capacity determines the scope of activity we can shelter and the revenue potential implied long before final building plan, form and appearance are established.

Annexation and sprawl currently symbolize our approach to land conversion for shelter construction. Regulating land use relationships with zoning has proven to be a partial answer since this is not simply a matter of compatibility. This concept has stimulated sprawl and unnecessary consumption of an irreplaceable resource. Its limited success has encouraged annexation for more shelter and revenue since the effort gives the illusion of fiscal responsibility over the term of an elected official. This often proves inadequate over time as the annexed area ages and its “new” revenue does not keep pace with the city’s increase in public service cost per acre. Further annexation continues the illusion with more sprawl that often seeks future fiscal rescue with more consumption of a limited resource.

The problem continues because the physical relationship between shelter capacity, activity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance is not understood, cannot be defined, and cannot be mathematically correlated with economic potential. The result has been the promiscuous consumption of land in a blind search for an affordable and desirable quality of life. The tools available have simply been too limited to: (1) evaluate the entire set of options available; (2) build knowledge; and (3) produce leadership direction without unlimited consumption of our source of life.

The forecast models I’ve mentioned are based on a new classification system for building design based on the parking system employed. The result is six comprehensive categories that can produce increasing quantities of gross building area to shelter the many activity groups we have created. This is significant because the amount of gross building area in a city combines with permitted occupant activity to determine the majority of revenue received per buildable acre. The total received must equal a city’s total average annual cost per acre to operate. When it doesn’t a city begins to discuss the alternatives available to balance its budget.

Two templates, or forecast models, have been created for each building design category to predict either:

1)      The gross building area capacity of a given land area based on a given building design category and the values entered in the shaded cells of its design specification panel, or 

2)      The buildable land area required for a given gross building area objective based on a given building design category and the values entered in the shaded cells of its design specification panel.

A forecast model has been created for each of the objectives mentioned above for each building design category. An algorithm in each model processes the values entered for use by its master equation. The equation has been derived to answer one of the two questions above for a given building design category. Results are predicted for a series of floor quantity options entered in the first column of the model’s forecast panel. The gross building area or buildable land area results vary with floor quantity option considered. These options are translated into shelter capacity per buildable acre, intensity, intrusion, and dominance implications with the help of the equations noted in the implications module of the forecast model. The correlation of building category, design specification, forecast panel, and implications module permits the measurement and evaluation needed to build knowledge regarding the capacity of land, quality of life, and intensity implied by the specification values under consideration.

When gross building area can be accurately predicted or measured per acre, anything that is a function of the building square feet involved, such as cost, revenue, location, condition, population, traffic volume, and so on can be measured, estimated, or correlated to achieve a given objective within a city’s incorporated limits. It is the correlation of capacity, activity, intensity, location, and condition per acre that determines a city’s ability to meet a revenue objective and afford a desired quality of life.

To my knowledge, this is the first time that strategic architectural design decisions and implications have been separated, measured, and predicted in mathematical terms that have the potential to lead. Strategic decisions precede such tactical decisions as: building appearance; building form; building setbacks; floor plan subdivision; parking arrangement; site plan appearance; engineering sytems; and so on. Strategic decisions determine the shelter capacity, intensity, intrusion, and dominance present or proposed by the relationship of building mass, pavement, and unpaved open space specified for a given buildable land area. These decisions produce gross building area results and shelter capacity per buildable acre that have not been correlated with permitted activity to achieve an economic objective. They are, however, the foundation for tactical decisions that determine what we see. In other words, strategic and tactical decisions combine to produce and symbolize the quality of life we create.

I’ve called the forecast model package Shelter Capacity Evaluation for want of a better title, and written about earlier versions in my first book with McGraw-Hill in 2001. It relates in my opinion to: city planning, urban design, landscape architecture, architecture, civil engineering, government, law, zoning; real estate development, environmental assessment, demography, appraisal, banking, and investment. These are at least some of the professions that consume or evaluate land to provide shelter for all human activity.

I’ve pursued this effort because I believe we must do a much better job of predicting the capacity of land to shelter the many activities of growing populations within a geographically limited Built Domain. Annexation and sprawl currently symbolize the threat this lack of leadership ability represents.

I am attaching a copy of a sample spreadsheet that predicts the gross building area potential of a given land area based on the variables entered in the shaded cells of its template. It pertains to the G1 Building Design Category (G1 buildings have surface parking around, but not under, the building on the same premise.) When the gross land area is given the forecast model is labeled G1.L1. When a gross building area objective is given and the objective is to determine the buildable land area needed given various floor quantity options, the forecast model is labeled G1.B1. 

PS: I would like to introduce the forecast models I’ve created as a subscription software application and am inquiring if you would be willing to undertake this effort in the hope of multiplying your investment as a percentage of its profit. I am not interested in pursuing the sales and marketing associated with the business aspects of this effort, but am willing to serve as a consultant. I will only respond to investors I consider serious with a proven business track record and a willingness to explore new opportunities.